Film: “Le Concert”
Last night, I watched a French/Russian comedy/drama entitled “Le Concert” (or The Concert) after a friend recommended the film to me. I had actually read various reviews about it and these could not be more extreme: some film critics completely trashed it and others hailed it as a great film. So, I decided to watch it to understand why my friend liked it and also to make up my own mind.
“Le Concert” has elements of farce and is at times very funny, as well as witty. There is implicit criticism not only for the communist regime in the former Soviet Union but also for dictatorships in general and the destructive effect that these have on the arts. Many critics said that the film was too sentimental and suffered from an “overwhelming” respect for the “high brow” established music like Tchaikovsky’s Concerto for Violin and Orchestra in D major, which forms the core of the movie. It may well be true but personally, I didn’t think so!
The first half of the film is excellent, as the former conductor and his band of musicians rush through frantic preparations (and a wave of funny if implausible deceptions) to travel to Paris and play Tchaikovsky’s violin concerto, posing as the orchestra of the Bolshoi, with French violin virtuosa Anne-Marie Jacquet. The reasons why become clear in flashbacks as the film progresses. I did get a little annoyed and slightly bored with the story once the musicians arrived in France. There are then many clichés and they all turn obnoxious due to alcohol and money. However, the at times “run away” plot is always brought together again by Andrey Filipov (the conductor convincingly played by Aleksey Guskov) and the violinist Anne-Marie Jacquet, the excellent and charming Mélanie Laurent. But the real reason why this film is worth watching is its finale with the performance of the concert of the title: Tchaikovsky’s Violin Concerto in D major at the beautiful Théâtre du Châtelet in Paris. Mélanie Laurent does a truly great job during the concert and you are left believing that she is realy performing the piece. Of course, the violin is in reality played by the lady who coached Laurent, Sarah Nemtanu, first violinist of the Orchestre Nationale de France. Her rendition of Tchaikovsky’s piece is beautifully moving, delicate, sensitive and technically flawless. The concert is the climax of the film and the reasons why become obvious during the conductor’s memory flashbacks.
So my conclusion…Well, I loved it! Sentimental? Yes! Implausible? Of course! A great film? No! But ultimately, who cares?
The music is sublime and the film leaves you with a feeling of warmth and happiness or better, it leaves you in a positive frame of mind. In today’s world, I think this is something precious that should truly be treasured! The rest is irrelevant chatter!
